California rail consultants repay $1.34M after watchdog flags Tiki bar, escape room trips

California rail consultants repay $1.34M after watchdog flags Tiki bar, escape room trips

Four consulting firms accused of improperly billing the California High-Speed Rail Authority for travel, including trips to restaurants and bars, have returned more than $1 million to the state while a review of their expenses continues.

Read more Fed up with gang violence, thousands flood Haiti’s streets to thank Bukele

Rail authority CFO Jamey Matalka announced during a recent board meeting that the contractors had begun returning money. The agency confirmed Monday it had recovered all of $1.34 million.

That’s more than what the rail authority’s inspector general says the agency paid for consultant travel not allowed by state and contract rules. It’s also more than the overall travel expense amount the inspector general reviewed.

The says consultants billed the rail authority for travel to places that appeared unrelated to state business. That includes a Planet Fitness gym, an escape room, a Tiki bar, a nightclub and restaurants, among other places. The report also noted improper out-of-state and international travel expenses.

“We are doing a broader review than just what the (Office of the Inspector General) had conducted,” Matalka said during the Oct. 28 board meeting, which occurred the same day former CEO Ian Choudri resigned from the rail authority.

Choudri has not confirmed that he resigned because of the findings, which troubled even high-speed rail’s supporters in state government and led to stricter consultant reimbursement rules. The resignation came as Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra also acknowledged a lack of public trust in the project and floated a leadership shake-up for the rail authority.

The inspector general’s review followed allegations that the agency had covered improper travel expenses submitted between June 2024 and April 2026 by the four consulting firms.

The firms are program management contractor AECOM-Fluor JV, track design contractor SYSTRA|TYPSA JV, financial adviser KPMG LLP and legal adviser Nossaman LLP.

For its part, the rail authority failed to follow state rules requiring it to evaluate the business need for consultants’ travel before reimbursing it, according to the report. The agency’s contract managers also sometimes signed off on the expenses based on assumptions that the CEO approved of them, the report says.

In total, the report says the agency approved $800,900 in travel expenses with “little to no upfront consideration” for how appropriate they were. Approved expenses worth $543,000 were not allowed by contract requirements and $81,000 appeared unallowable under state rules, the report says.

Read more 3 brothers vanished in 2010. Why is their father facing murder charges now?

Reimbursement is ‘not admission,’ CA rail contractor says

Matalka’s board report Oct. 28 showed the four contractors returned the following amounts to the rail authority, which is again reviewing travel expenses:

  • AECOM-Fluor JV returned $448,600.
  • SYSTRA|TYPSA JV returned $363,100.
  • KPMG LLP returned $486,700.
  • Nossaman LLP returned $37,000.

Of the four contractors, only KPMG responded to The Fresno Bee’s request for comment Monday about the allegations in the inspector general’s report. The report indicates KPMG was the contractor that “most commonly” billed travel costs that appeared unrelated to state business.

The company does not intend to recover any of the money it gave back, but spokesperson Russ Grote said KPMG’s outside counsel found that “only a small percentage of the expenses may have been ineligible for reimbursement.”

“Recognizing the importance of public trust and in the spirit of good faith, we reimbursed the Authority for all expenses identified in the September (Office of the Inspector General) report,” Grote said in an email. “Our full reimbursement to the Authority is not an admission of wrongdoing.”

CA rail authority implementing corrective actions

The rail authority’s board held a special meeting Oct. 9 to review the inspector general’s findings. Matalka, the CFO, said at the time that contracts require consultants to bill the rail authority accurately and support charges with receipts.

He added that the “vast majority of our controls are operating efficiently,” but the agency is also working on 10 corrective actions. They include travel rules training for agency staff and consultants, updating travel policy and automated invoice reviews that check charges against state and contract rules, among other changes.

Board Chair Steve Kawa said during that meeting that he took the inspector general’s findings “with the utmost seriousness.”

“Billing the state, the taxpayers, unallowable travel expenses, failing to follow required procedures and lapses in basic accountability by management are issues that must be corrected,” Kawa said. “And they will be.”

On Oct. 28, Matalka said six of the 10 corrective actions were complete and that the agency was ahead of schedule on implementing the rest.

Read more Schools closed, roads swamped as a foot of rain floods Broward overnight

Post Comment