Notre Dame’s Offense Still A Work In Progress, And That Is Fine

Notre Dame has outscored opponents 120-23 so far this year. By any regular standard, this would be considered excellent both offensively and defensively.

But this year is different for the Irish, and the standard is title-level winning performances and consistency. And in this regard, despite the wide scoring margin and output, Notre Dame’s offense is still nowhere near its full potential and has some things to clean up if it hopes to make a deep CFP run.

Read more FAU takes advantage of turnovers, poor run game in 16-10 Shula Bowl win over FIU

The Notre Dame run game is still in flux, but the running back picture is becoming clearer

Irish fans are thrilled the team is 3-0, but that doesn’t mean things are perfect and no improvements are needed. The Irish run game has looked clunky at times so far this season.

The timing seems off; there’s a lack of push, and it just feels a bit out of sync too often for anyone’s comfort. This offensive line has new faces in new places all over it, from two new tackles to a few right guards; there’s a lot that still needs to “gel” before this offense can fully take off.

The offensive line is one part of the equation; the running backs are the second. Everyone appreciates Aneyas Williams for sticking with Notre Dame when it would have been very easy to transfer somewhere else and not sit behind Jeremiah Love and JD Price. That’s Irish loyalty.

The only problem with this is that Nolan James is outperforming him. James just seems to have more burst, more lateral speed, and more juice overall, most recently shown by his 125-yard outing against the Spartans. James feels like the right guy, and once that’s more established moving forward, the run game will have more consistency.

HERE COME THE IRISH

Goodnight, Irish Nation!#GoIrishpic.twitter.com/6quHgRDvSC

– Notre Dame Football (@NDFootball) September 20, 2026

Micah Gilbert has a breakout performance

CJ Carr needs more reliable downfield targets than just Jordan Faison. And through the first couple of games, Irish fans were waiting for one or more other receivers to emerge and fill this role.

With that in mind as the backdrop, Micah Gilbert’s terrific 170-yard output, highlighted by a 61-yard bomb to start the game, was exactly what this team needed.

Read more Padres edge Marlins as San Diego tightens wild-card

Carr is capable of taking this offense to heights we haven’t seen in modern Notre Dame history, but he needs help. Perhaps against Purdue, Jaden Greathouse or Mylan Graham can have a night like Gilbert, or he can put on a repeat showing.

There’s also the possibility that the Irish get Quincy Porter back from a knee injury later this year, which could provide a huge spark as well.

The reality is that the Notre Dame offense is very much a work in progress, and progress is being made as the team collects lopsided wins along the way. What a great, healthy place to be.

Today’s best reads

• Notre Dame Suffocates Michigan State: Instant Takeaways
• Notre Dame Is Starting to Look Like the Heyday Patriots
• Notre Dame Football Routs Rice: What Went Right and Wrong
• Should Notre Dame Be on Upset Alert Against Michigan State? Staff Predictions
• Thoughts After Attending Notre Dame’s Cooking of Rice

This article was originally published on www.si.com/college/notredame as Notre Dame’s Offense Still A Work In Progress, And That Is Fine.

Copyright ABG-SI LLC. SPORTS ILLUSTRATED is a registered trademark of ABG-SI LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Read more Russian exiles cast votes to voice dissent to Putin and Ukraine war

This story was originally published September 20, 2026 at 10:45 AM.