FHP’s loosened chase rules kill innocent bystanders, others. Here’s what to know

FHP’s loosened chase rules kill innocent bystanders, others. Here’s what to know

A Miami Herald investigation found that Florida Highway Patrol pursuits tripled and deaths climbed nearly fivefold after the agency gave troopers broad license to chase and ram fleeing drivers in December 2023. The latest to die was 15-year-old Brody Swain, killed on his mother’s birthday in July after a trooper used a controversial maneuver to stop the SUV he was riding in.

Read more University of Miami trustees chairman to lead Byron Donalds’ transition team

FULL STORY: A sleepover and a spin in mom’s car: 15-year-old latest to die in FHP chase

Read more Death row pastor asks Florida’s next governor for 6-month pause on executions

Here are key takeaways:

  • The death toll: At least 34 people have died in FHP pursuits in the nearly three years since the policy change, compared with seven in the prior three years. In 2024 alone, 17 people died — more than triple the five killed the year before.
  • Innocent bystanders are paying the price. Nearly 1 in 3 of those killed had no involvement in the alleged crime, including 74-year-old Bonnie Bouffard, who had pulled over onto the Florida Turnpike shoulder shortly before an FHP trooper rammed a suspect’s truck at 90 mph. The truck careened into Bouffard’s car, killing her.
  • FHP stands alone among 12 major Florida law-enforcement agencies reviewed by the Herald. Miami Police ban pursuits except for violent felons; the Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office calls PIT maneuvers “unsanctioned”; Palm Beach County classifies forcible stops like PIT maneuvers as deadly force. FHP encourages the PIT maneuver as “the primary technique” and allows wrong-way driving.
  • The policy traces to Dave Kerner, appointed by Gov. Ron DeSantis to lead the state’s highway safety department after Kerner crossed party lines to endorse him. On a 2023 podcast, Kerner said he directs troopers to execute a PIT “as soon as practical” when a vehicle flees — telling listeners a trooper will “put you in a ditch.”
  • Brody Swain was killed July 26 after a trooper hit the SUV he was in — driven by his 15-year-old friend on a learner’s permit — with a PIT maneuver during a chase over speeding. FHP has refused to identify the trooper or release records, even to Brody’s parents. Read the full investigation at miamiherald.com/wreckedlives.

This report was produced with the assistance of a proprietary tool powered by artificial intelligence and using our own originally reported, written and published content. It was reviewed and edited by our journalists.

Read more Salazar declared winner of Miami congressional race after two-day recount

This story was originally published November 5, 2026 at 3:06 PM.

Post Comment