Coral Gables reelects Mayor Lago, votes in newcomer Whiting. A third race is close

Coral Gables reelects Mayor Lago, votes in newcomer Whiting. A third race is close

Coral Gables voters on Tuesday reelected Mayor Vince Lago and added newcomer Dominique “Nikki” Whiting to the City Commission — but a third race, between Commissioner Melissa Castro and challenger Nestor Menendez, appears headed for a recount.

Read more Giménez wins fourth term in Congress, defeating Ehr in tighter Miami rematch

Just before 11 p.m., preliminary results had Menendez ahead of Castro, the Group IV incumbent, by 123 votes. That puts the race just outside of the half-percentage point margin that can trigger a recount under Florida law.

Menendez declared victory Tuesday night, telling the Miami Herald he feels “blessed that things broke my way.” Castro said she plans to ask for a recount but did call Menendez to congratulate him.

“I want to see it with my eyes,” Castro told the Herald Tuesday night, stating that “very sadly our administration and legal system is not to trust. So when the recount does happen, I would very much like to be there.”

Preliminary results show Lago secured nearly 57% of the vote to win a fourth and final term, beating out two longtime residents: Laureano Cancio and Jackson “Rip” Holmes, who nabbed about 26% and 18% of the vote, respectively.

“The city won today. It was a strong statement and, to me, it’s vindication,” Lago said about voters’ support for him, Whiting and Menendez during his watch party with supporters at Wolfe’s Wine Shoppe on Miracle Mile, where he was joined by Menendez, Vice Mayor Rhonda Anderson and Commissioner Richard Lara. “After a [failed] recall, after the referendums, after the last election, the residents have been very, very clear on what they want and the type of leadership that they want and what they’re not willing to accept anymore here in the city.”

Whiting, a fundraiser with Florida International University, defeated opponent Gonzalo Sanabria with about 56% of the vote, according to the preliminary results. Whiting will fill the Group V seat being vacated by Commissioner Ariel Fernandez, who opted not to run for reelection.

While Whiting is now the youngest person on the commission at age 33, she comes to office with an extensive political resume. The millennial previously held senior positions in the executive office of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, the Florida Department of Health, and with former lieutenant governor and current FIU president Jeanette Nuñez. She drew a lengthy list of endorsements, including from Lago and Anderson, and raised over $125,000 in campaign donations.

Read more Co-pilot who died in Palm Beach County plane crash was 20-year-old woman

“Working in various levels of government, I felt prepared, and honestly, I just trust in God’s plan,” Whiting said at her election watch party after the results came out. “The credit goes to Him, and I just felt, you know, if it’s meant for me, it’s meant for me. If not, you know, the sun shines tomorrow.”

When Whiting thinks about the future, the new commissioner said she wants to explore ways to help incentivize young homeownership in the Gables.

If Menendez is declared the winner, his election will mark an end to the dramatic and routine telenovela-worthy disputes between Lago and Castro during commission meetings. The election of Menendez and Whiting, two candidates Lago supported, would be a significant shakeup to the five-member City Commission.

“I feel validated. … I feel very, very blessed and grateful for all the people that supported me because it was a team effort,” Menendez said, pointing out that Castro put up a good race. He said he plans to do a listening tour to hear from residents and employees about their concerns.

“I think it’s very important that I just listen for now, right? I listen, and I always keep Coral Gables first,” he said.

As for the mayor, Lago said he has big plans for his final two years in office, including the restoration of historic landmarks, the opening of more parks and the creation of the Mobility Hub, a newly renovated parking garage that he believes will help attract more shoppers and diners to the business district.

“I feel at peace,” Lago said about winning reelection. “At the end of the day, if you look at my body of work, I think the message is clear. I’ve always put the city first, whether it’s the referendums, whether it’s my fiscal responsibility, or my support for law and order, or for a downtown, which is really the backbone of this community, financially — I’ve always put the city first.”

Read more What we know about the victims of the Palm Beach County plane crash

Miami Herald staff writer Olivia Lloyd contributed reporting.

This story was originally published November 3, 2026 at 9:22 PM.

Post Comment