A bulldozer-friendly state law threatens art deco hotels — so Miami Beach is suing

A bulldozer-friendly state law threatens art deco hotels — so Miami Beach is suing

In an attempt to spare the historic Savoy and Arlington hotels from a wrecking ball, Miami Beach officials agreed Wednesday to challenge Florida’s “widely criticized” Resiliency and Safe Structures Act.

Read more Payouts to FL immigration contractors surpass $1.2B, outstanding debts remain

The owner of the Savoy Hotel and Beach Club and the Arlington Hotel, citing the act, filed to build a new project at the sites that would involve the demolition of both structures, city spokeswoman Melissa Berthier said in a statement. The Savoy, built in 1937, and the Arlington, built in 1941, are “considered architecturally significant examples of Miami Beach art deco and the classical revival style of architecture,” the statement said.

Approved by Florida lawmakers in 2024, the Resiliency and Safe Structures Act prohibits Miami Beach and other cities from imposing restrictions on the demolition or reconstruction of certain vulnerable coastal buildings — specifically, in cases where the structures don’t meet current flood elevation standards, were deemed unsafe or ordered to be torn down.

“Our 14 local and four National Register historic districts are the foundation of Miami Beach’s character and global charm,” Miami Beach Mayor Steven Meiner said in the statement. “A law that treats some of them as expendable is worth challenging.”

Both historic hotels, at 425 and 455 Ocean Drive, are classified as contributing structures within the Ocean Beach Local Historic District, recognized as a certified local district by the U.S. National Park Service. The structures have distinctive low-scale massing, streamlined forms and geometric ornamentation, the statement said.

Read more Is South Florida experiencing a ‘rain bomb?’ Here’s what to know

Miami Beach Commissioner Alex Fernandez, who called for legal action, said in a statement that all of Miami Beach should have been exempt from the act in the first place, pointing to full exemptions carved out in St. Augustine, Key West, Palm Beach, Tampa, Pensacola, West Palm Beach, Bal Harbour, Sanibel and Panama City.

The law only spares portions of Miami Beach — the dedicated Art Deco District and only parts of Ocean Drive — representing an “arbitrary determination by the Florida legislature that some areas of the state are worthy of historic preservation while others are less worthy,” Fernandez said. Once a historic building is demolished, it is lost forever, ruining architectural legacies, the commissioner added.

Miami Beach’s seven-member commission voted unanimously to allow the city attorney’s office to file a lawsuit challenging the statute.

“No fight is more important than to save the historic buildings that make unique Miami Beach in the world,” Fernandez said. “They are simply irreplaceable.”

Read more Live updates: Broward swamped with a ‘rain bomb.’ Here’s the latest on crisis

Post Comment