Washington’s trans girls sports ban to start Dec. 3. Medical groups want it paused

Washington’s trans girls sports ban to start Dec. 3. Medical groups want it paused

Major Washington medical organizations are pushing for a pause on Initiative 638, a measure approved by voters earlier this month that would ban transgender girl athletes from playing in girls sports.

Read more Jury weighs fate of South Florida pastor at center of Haiti presidential killing

In a Nov. 17 news release, the groups cited ethical, practical and privacy concerns surrounding I-638’s implementation.

Nearly 56% of Washington voters were supporting the initiative scheduled to take effect Dec. 3 as of Tuesday morning.

“While we recognize the public’s concern for fairness in sports, as statewide medical organizations we are deeply troubled by the initiative’s mandate imposing medically unnecessary examinations and verification requirements on girls participating in school sports,” the coalition wrote in the release from the Washington State Medical Association.

Other organizations with the coalition include the Washington Academy of Family Physicians, the Washington section of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the state’s chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Washington Academy of Physician Associates, the Washington State Psychiatric Association and the American College of Physicians’ Washington chapter.

Let’s Go Washington, the political group that backed the initiative, is refuting the coalition’s claims.

The medical groups are supporting a lawsuit brought last week that aims to halt the initiative from taking effect. In that case, plaintiff parents and TransFamilies are represented by the ACLU of Washington and Legal Voice, while the Washington Education Association is represented by Pacifica Law Group.

I-638 received broad support from Washingtonians during this month’s midterms, which otherwise saw Democrats seize a supermajority in the state House.

Its proponents say the measure would return fairness to girls sports, arguing that trans girl athletes have unfair physical advantages in competitions. But detractors contend that the initiative discriminates against trans girl athletes and that it would install hurdles to participation in girls’ athletics that aren’t there for boys.

Initiative 638 would require girl athletes to provide a consent form or signed statement from their provider verifying their biological sex via “reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels.”

But what that would look like — including whether it could lead to “invasive medical exams,” as some opponents claim — has been the subject of fierce debate.

Read more Bulls, Nets look to gain traction after identical 3-10 starts

The medical coalition wrote in Tuesday’s news release that I-638 doesn’t identify how physicians must comply with its verification requirements.

“For example, it is unclear whether physicians would be required to conduct examinations of girls’ ‘reproductive anatomy,’” the group said. “Such exams are not part of today’s routine sports physicals and are not medically necessary to determine whether a child can safely participate in athletics.”

The group added that the mere possibility of such an exam may deter some girls from participating in sports.

LGW spokeswoman Hallie Herzberg said I-638 doesn’t authorize or require exams of any sort, and that medical organizations are irresponsibly twisting its wording into something it wouldn’t do. She provided a statement from Dr. Michael A. Welsh of Buckley, a board-certified family medicine physician, saying the initiative doesn’t mandate any kind of exam.

“The only designation for medical professionals that conduct routine sport’s (sic) physicals is that they verify the sex of their patient which doctors already do in the course of the appointment,” Welsh’s statement continued. “As a medical provider, I have access to information on my patients in their medical records and that information is sufficient for me to check a box designating their sex.”

The anti-initiative medical coalition said in Tuesday’s news release that an estimated quarter of Washington kids don’t have a personal clinician. It noted that many school districts offer free sports physicals, but that the measure doesn’t address how those — which often are held in public and school settings — would be conducted moving ahead. That, they argue, could ultimately create roadblocks to sports participation.

They also claim that the cost of testosterone- or genetic lab testing could disproportionately impact lower-income students.

Last week’s lawsuit was filed in King County Superior Court. The medical coalition says it plans to submit a formal amicus brief in support of the preliminary injunction.

Meanwhile, the attorneys with the Alliance Defending Freedom representing Female Athletes United filed a motion late last week asking the court to let the FAU — a nonprofit with Washington female-athlete members affected by I-638 — defend the new law.

“Girls deserve equal opportunity, fairness, and safety, and more than 1.7 million voters said so,” Kristen Waggoner, ADF’s president, CEO and chief counsel said in a Nov. 13 news release. “It is shameful that the ACLU would sue to take that away from our daughters.”

Read more Belen’s 30th region title run. Lourdes soccer ends Heritage streak. Football playoffs, more region runs

This story was originally published November 17, 2026 at 7:10 PM.

Post Comment