At 1-8, what’s clear and what needs to be figured out in this Dolphins rebuild

At 1-8, what’s clear and what needs to be figured out in this Dolphins rebuild

It’s for the best, Dolphins fans.

Yes, this 24-22 loss at the Colts might have stung, just as the 229 other losses that came previously during this depressing century of Dolphins football.

Read more Republican 2028 field takes shape after midterm drubbing

But once it became clear over the first eight games that Malik Willis likely isn’t the long-term answer at quarterback, and once it became evident that you cannot will into existence making Kyle McCord another Brock Purdy, the health of this franchise rests on landing the best draft pick possible to give you the best and most options possible.

By falling to 1-8, Miami stayed third in the jockeying for draft position — just behind the 0-8 Chargers and 1-8 Titans – but ahead of the 2-8 Jets and 2-7 Eagles.

It’s a taboo topic, of course. Jeff Hafley, understandably, will look at you like you have three ears if you bring it up.

But let’s be real here: If you’re looking at this rebuild with any sort of long-term pragmatism, a win Sunday would have been damaging because the Jets own the 3-7 Colts’ first-round pick, and Miami — with a win — would have ended the day behind two Jets picks in the first-round draft order.

Miami already is at a disadvantage because it would lose a draft tiebreaker to every other lousy team, by virtue of the Dolphins’ opponents boasting the league’s best winning percentage.

Sunday reminded us of this truism during a rebuild: When you’re analyzing position units on a young team, the evaluations can swing wildly. Growth of young players isn’t consistently linear. So conclusions should never be drawn off a single day.

One day, you think (hope?) that this defensive tackle room might be good enough, at least for the next couple of years while other positions are addressed.

Then you lose Zach Sieler and Zeek Biggers, and you watch the Colts gouge Miami’s run defense (172 yards, 5.1 per carry), and you realize that Kenneth Grant probably cannot be projected as an impact starter. And you realize you’re going to need to augment that room with at least one difference maker to supplement Jordan Phillips, who left in the fourth quarter with an arm injury.

One day, Greg Dulcich looks like a poor man’s Dalton Kincaid or Sam LaPorta and you wonder if the Dolphins can contend for a playoff berth with a Dulcich/Will Kacmarek tight end combo. Then there are moments like Sunday, where tight ends catch one pass for five yards (by Kacmarek) and Dulcich begins the day with a false start penalty after a week when coaches told players they must stop doing that.

One day, you watch Jacob Rodriguez record 18 tackles against the Vikings, and you can dream of a Zach Thomas clone anchoring the Dolphins defense for a decade.

Then you watch him make just one tackle and too often look helpless against the Colts’ running game, and you wonder if he will become a Pro Bowl caliber player or merely a decent starter. Like all middle linebackers, Rodriguez is somewhat dependent on defensive tackles effectively occupying blockers so that he can fly around unimpeded. Rodriguez didn’t have that luxury Sunday with Sieler out and Biggers and Phillips leaving with injuries during the game.

In September, you see rookie cornerback Chris Johnson allow two touchdowns in two weeks and wonder if the Dolphins should have just kept Jaylen Waddle.

Two months later, you see Johnson picking off passes on consecutive weeks – including a pick six Sunday – and realize this trade (for the 27th pick and draft selections that became Chris Bell and Trey Moore) was the better play than keeping Waddle, who has pedestrian numbers for Denver (30 catches, 337 yards, two touchdowns).

Much like in life, NFL evaluations can change minute to minute.

One minute, you watched Kyle McCord throwing with poise and accuracy in navigating a Dolphins comeback in his first NFL start on Sunday.

And then you watch him throw a near interception (negated by an unrelated penalty)… and watch him throw two other critical late-game passes that were batted down… and watch him seemingly unaware of a couple of damaging blitzes, including one that ended with a Colts recovered fumble in the end zone.

In McCord’s defense, his receivers couldn’t consistently separate from Colts’ defensive backs. And several others share more of the blame for a critical late-game sack when CJ Allen rushed unencumbered between Patrick Paul and Ollie Gordon to dump McCord, leading to a 4th and 17.

Read more El Niño still growing stronger. Here’s what could happen next

McCord was by no means a disaster, closing 17 for 32 for 209 yards (a 73.6 passer rating), with a rushing touchdown but also that critical fumble at the goal line. He threw away a couple of passes and Caleb Douglas dropped another.

But if you were hoping McCord would become the second coming of Purdy, well, that didn’t happen Sunday. He will remain the starter, though it’s Malik Willis’ job when he returns from his core muscle injury. (A decision hasn’t been made on whether Willis needs surgery, Hafley said.)

So after this 1-8 start, and the fluctuations in performance that’s typical of rookies, what exactly should the Dolphins know, besides the heartening evidence that Jon-Eric Sullivan knows how to draft?

Here are five things that are already clear before the final eight games, at least from this perspective:

▪ They’re not quite good enough on either line. There are strong building blocks (on offense) with Kadyn Proctor, Aaron Brewer (who was sorely missed Sunday) and Paul, but Jonah Savaiinaea will need competition at guard and the Dolphins obviously will need to replace Austin Jackson by either moving Proctor to right tackle or prioritizing that in the offseason.

Defensively, Sieler needs to be retained (perhaps on a restructured deal) and Biggers looks like he could be a competent backup swing tackle/end. But even as stout as Phillips has been, he shouldn’t be your top defensive tackle longterm.

▪ They need at least two more playmakers that defenses need to game-plan against. Ideally, one would be a receiver and another a tight end. Besides De’Von Achane, the Dolphins have (at least) three other skill position keepers with Douglas, Malik Washington and Ollie Gordon — who were all again very good Sunday.

▪ They need to draft a kicker. Zane Gonzalez’s regrettable Dolphins tenure continued Sunday with missed 47- and 51-yard field goals and an errant extra point.

▪ They need to draft a quarterback if there’s someone they have a conviction about. Leaving the position unaddressed and simply hoping Willis can replicate what he did in a single game this season (against the Jets) is no way to run a franchise.

▪ They need two heavy-usage edge players — three, if Josh Uche isn’t re-signed.

There are a bunch of looming decisions that I would put in the “need to see more” basket:

▪ Whether to exercise Chop Robinson’s 2028 fifth-year option, with a decision due by May 1. That option projects for the $16.5 million range, a steep figure if Miami determines he’s a pass rush specialist and not an every-down player.

Robinson had his fifth sack of the season on Sunday and at least five more pressures. His excellent work as a pass rusher makes a compelling case to exercise the option. But his final eight games – and his work against the run over that stretch – will be telling.

▪ Whether the team needs one starting safety, two or none. Michael Taaffe continues to make a strong case, snagging his third interception Sunday. Dante Trader Jr. has had some good moments. But this remains a decision in progress.

▪ Whether to re-sign JuJu Brents with the intent of constructing the cornerback room around him, Johnson and another good young cornerback who’s not yet on the roster. Brents allowed a TD pass Sunday but has been generally solid. This decision, too, must play out.

There are other unanswered questions, but that’s enough for a day that presumably left some Dolphins fans in the dumps but others with their eye on the real prize (a top two pick in April’s draft).

Read more Oil falls as recovering Middle East exports bolster surplus outlook

Here’s what Hafley said after the game and news on two more injuries.

This story was originally published November 15, 2026 at 5:37 PM.

Post Comment